Creativity & PD – It’s Maddening!     by Peggy Willocks

 
   

 

What do creativity and Parkinson's have to do with each other?   Must one be intelligent to be creative?  Are mental illnesses and creativity linked?  These were questions to which I set out to find answers.  Although I didn’t come up with any definitive answers, I did discover that I am amazed at the talents seen in people with Parkinson's (PWP).  Not alone in this quest for an answers, I also began wondering if PWP's creative abilities manifested themselves "before" or "after" their diagnosis of PD. 

   
Just marvel at the submissions in this issue!  The talent and uniqueness of each one is phenomenal.  Is it that many do not work and have more time to release these bottled-up expressions of our inner selves after PD, or is there something else relating to our lack of dopamine (or maybe an over-production of another brain chemical)?  I'll leave that to the researchers!  It has been clearly shown in a myriad of cases that writing, visual arts, and doing something with our hands and minds are therapeutic.  (Do you know of any psychiatric unit that doesn't incorporate occupational therapy into its programs?)  But I think there is more to it that therapy alone.

After I was diagnosed with Parkinson's, I almost had this obsession of "producing" in an attempt to try to prove that I could beat the disease. And maybe therein lies the answer to the original question.  Do PWP's manifest their creativity "before" or "after" their diagnosis of PD?  Possibly, when a person is initially diagnosed with a progressive, incurable disease they kick into a "fight or flight" mode.  What I mean is a person either goes into deep depression and a "Woe is me!" attitude, a simple "Acceptance" mode, or an "I'll show you!" thinking of how to handle such an occurrence.  It all depends on a trait that comes in this neat little package called "attitude." 

Let's take writing for an example.  You’ll find many writing contributions in this issue.  Writing is therapeutic, inexpensive, and can be produced with little effort.  In The Observer - "Easy as ABC" - Jim Pollard writes, "If it were a drug, this versatile little treatment would surely have a public profile to match Viagra. Indeed, the lack of a pharmaceutical company to promote it is perhaps part of the reason why its benefits are so little known. It's cheaper than any drug - the cost of a pen and paper. Because the miracle treatment is simply what I am doing right now: writing."   I might add that in the case of PWP's, if the pen and paper requirement is a physical problem, we have the computer with a variety of assistive technological capabilities to allow us to produce.

Most PWP are also quite intelligent (or so I'd like to claim).  However, many often suffer from some form of mental illness (and I'd like to disclaim this!). When I think those in the PD community, I think of those who are obsessive compulsive, paranoid, depressed, anxious, among other diagnoses.  Could this be due to difficulty in balancing our dopamine levels accurately and having to be done synthetically (through the use of mind-altering drugs)? Is the dopaminergic response to producing something creative involved?  Do you recall the picture of the mad scientist?  Maybe he/she suffered from a neurological illness!  In an article called, "Creativity tied to Mental Illness" (William Cromie - Harvard News), it states, "Scientists have wondered for a long time why madness and creativity seem linked, particularly in artists, musicians, and writers," notes Shelley Carson, a Harvard psychologist . . .  "That's exactly what our research is about," Carson comments. "It shows that, to be creative, you can be bright and crazy, but not stupid."  

Another angle to look at the question here is this:  Are creative people more prone to have Parkinson's?  We could go on indefinitely with possible theories, but one thing I am sure we will agree upon beyond a shadow of a doubt - there's some awesomely creative work in this issue of Virtuality!

Additional links:

 Biodanza rehab
http://www.positivehealth.com/permit/Articles/Neurological/toro57.htm

Art for Parkinson's 

http://www.artforparkinsons.org.uk/home.html

PD & Therapeutic Writing
http://www.geocities.com/murraycharters/033.html

PD & Creativity
http://www.clognition.org/creativity.htm

http://www.creativityexplored.org/news/newsletters/spring_2002/

http://www.palmdigitalmedia.com/product/detail/12138

Pfizer creativity
http://www.pfizer.com/brain/etour5.html

Starting an Art Programme
http://www.artforparkinsons.org.uk/workshops.html

Voices
http://www.geocities.com/doncyberdadmckinley/dedicate.html

Mental Health
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/sci_cult/mentalhealth/genetics.htm